Could the RTBA (Read the Bills Act) really work?

The RTBA: Read the Bills Act
http://www.downsizedc.org/read_the_laws.shtml
would make it a requirement that proposed legislation be posted to the internet for 7 days prior to a vote in Congress and that the bills actually be read in Congress before the vote. Sounds like a good idea. Of course, it wouldn't be possible to have gargantuan complicated bills so Congress would need to change the way they approach the task of legislation. Could the RTBA work? Would it improve the way our government functions? Should it be proposed at the State government level, too?

Tags: congress, democracy, laws, legislation, rtba


 
Page 1 of 1
1.  

A Sad Testament To The State Of US Politics

Leader! Most 1st Place Votes
I mean, shouldn't this be a basic, obvious responsibility of our elected representatives?

Comments Discuss

 
25  votes
2.  

Yes laws MUST be read. Less laws is a good thing!

If this leads to less legislation, that would force congress to focus on the more important issues. Citizens and groups could read... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
15  votes
3.  

Stop Being LAZY! This can work. make it work.

Only when Americans are personally affected to they take action. This makes sense, anything less is UNPATRIOTIC!

Comments Discuss

 
14  votes
4.  

No more Patriot Acts!

This is the best way to prevent another act like the Patriot Act. If the American people were allowed to actually read it before ... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
13  votes
5.  

Good luck, but this just isn't a viable option.

This sounds great in theory. But in practice, things just aren't read. If the lawmakers in our country had to read or had to sit t... [show more]

Comments 7 Comments

 
11  votes
6.  

Can't hurt anything. Let's do it.

Even if it doesn't work for the majority, it would work for the minority of us who like to know what's going on _BEFORE_ it happens, not after.

Comments Discuss

 
9  votes
7.  
 
6  votes
8.  

Vote this in 100%

If this actually passed, it would slow congress down at first. But in the long run you would see bills get shorter and there woul... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
5  votes
9.  

Sunshine is the best disinfectant. - Justice L. Brandeis

Quote from Louis D. Brandeis, Supreme Court Justice 1916-1939

Comments Discuss

 
5  votes
10.  

Bills will be a lot less wordy anyway.

I don't think we'd see too many more 1000+ page bills coming out of congress.

Comments Discuss

 
5  votes
11.  

Utterly Unrealistic

Lawmakers can possibly be expected to read all of the bills submitted to Congress due to the sheer volume of pages. Like other or... [show more]

Comments 1 Comment

 
4  votes
12.  

In part, yes; the part about internet publishing

While we hope our representatives will read legislation, they simply don't have the time or the interest. Instead, we can rely on ... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
4  votes
13.  

They should start by reading the Constitution first!

If lawmakers would realize that the constitution exist as a set of guidelines for the type of laws that are legal in the first pla... [show more]

Comments 1 Comment

 
3  votes
14.  

Could be good, could be bad.

It would almost certainly kill pork barrel spending (good!), but it might also lead to a blogocracy, in which a few political blog... [show more]

Comments 7 Comments

 
3  votes
15.  

Other Initiatives Like This Have Failed

Does anyone remember the "Plain Speech" initiative? This would have been a law that would have required all bills to be translate... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
3  votes
16.  

Ideally, yeah. Bring it on. Love the Downsize DC. Go Jim Bab

I'm a member at Downsize DC and their practical approach to political advocacy grounds itself not on party lines, but true freedom... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
3  votes
17.  

Yes, and goes toward another possible solution.

A friend of mine said once that Congress should spend more time reviewing legislation and renewing out-of-date issues than passing... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
3  votes
18.  

It doesn't matter anymore

With a pathetic leader like Bush pissing off the entire world to the point that we are just a hair above the "axis of evil" on app... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
3  votes
19.  

What are we voting away?

I can't believe that bills up for vote aren't already posted to the internet for review by the average citizen. How are we suppos... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
2  votes
20.  

They know what they vote on.

Does the advertising revenue from this new site go to social programs? Government officials know what they are voting on. If I... [show more]

Comments Discuss

 
1  votes
  Add a new answer!  
 
Page 1 of 1

Topic History

ImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImgImg
See Older Activity
TheDevilHimself commented on the answer "Good luck, but this just isn't a viable option.": "I think it would be really nice if ...(2 years ago)

Comments     Leave a comment Leave a comment

Avatar Image
      Thumbs down Thumbs up   
missmolly missmolly: 116 points   2 years ago

This might actually work if we could also enforce a limit of one item per bill.

Bye-bye pork and every other horrible "rider".

Reply to this comment  Reply     Link to this comment Link
Avatar Image
      Thumbs down Thumbs up   
holotone holotone: 45,709 points   2 years ago

See also:
In which ways is Democracy inadequate?
http://www.grupthink.com/topic/129

Reply to this comment  Reply     Link to this comment Link
Avatar Image
      Thumbs down Thumbs up   
holotone holotone: 45,709 points   2 years ago

Can Technology Negate The Need For Representatives & Foster A True Democracy?
http://www.grupthink.com/topic/5293

Reply to this comment  Reply     Link to this comment Link
Avatar Image
      Thumbs down Thumbs up   
resymbol resymbol: 10 points   2 years ago

Doesn't this concept assume a basic literacy rate among our elected officials? I think the biggest hurdle in making something like this happen would be the massive training needed to insure literacy.

Reply to this comment  Reply     Link to this comment Link

Topic Details

This topic was started by Q.Random Q.Random: 127 points on March 8th, 2007. 58 grupies have voted on one or more of the 20 answers.

Tags: congress, democracy, laws, legislation, rtba

Get Notified

Get email notifications and feed updates on your home page by turning on the options below. You can also subscribe to topics automatically.

Please login or register to see notification options.